Summary for Educators

Conklin, M. M. (2025, November 24). How Socratic Seminars Can Empower Middle School Students. Edutopia.In “How Socratic Seminars Can Empower Middle School Students,” Megan Mary Conklin reflects on more than two decades of practice using Socratic seminars to deepen student thinking, strengthen communication skills, and build classroom community. She argues that the structure is uniquely powerful for middle school learners—students navigating a developmental period marked by emerging identity, increased social awareness, and a need for authentic voice. By shifting authority and talk-time from teacher to students, the Socratic seminar creates a space where young adolescents can engage meaningfully with ideas, develop reasoning skills, and learn to respectfully navigate differing viewpoints.

Conklin begins by describing her earliest experiences using seminars to explore complex texts, such as excerpts from Fahrenheit 451. Recently, she applied the structure to a culturally relevant topic circulating among her students—a viral “six-seven” meme. Rather than dismissing the fad, she used it as an entry point for inquiry, demonstrating how Socratic seminars can adapt to a wide range of texts including literature, artwork, songs, speeches, or articles. The power of the seminar lies in students arriving prepared, having annotated or questioned the text in advance, allowing the live discussion to be fully student-led.

A central feature of the seminar is open dialogue: students converse without raising hands, developing the ability to track nonverbal cues and recognize conversational openings. This norm is especially significant for students with disabilities or those who typically rely on adult mediation. Conklin shares the example of a student who uses a wheelchair and usually needs his paraprofessional to raise a hand for him. The seminar freed him from this constraint—an empowerment that he later described as “liberating.”

Another key principle is peer focus. Middle school students often default to directing comments toward the teacher, but over time, seminars train them to genuinely listen to one another, respond to peers’ ideas, and engage in authentic academic conversation. This peer-to-peer orientation strengthens collaboration and helps build a supportive classroom culture.

Conklin highlights the importance of building on ideas, an essential skill for adolescents still learning to move beyond disconnected comments. Using sentence stems and deliberate coaching, she helps students connect statements, synthesize viewpoints, and extend each other’s thinking. Over time, she notices students using these academic conversation moves even outside of seminars.

Students also develop questioning and critical thinking skills as they prepare a wide range of open-ended questions. These questions drive the seminar and invite deeper exploration of themes, meaning, or author intent. Sample student-generated questions from her “Six-Seven Seminar” show how even pop culture topics can prompt rich academic inquiry.

Respectful disagreement is another vital component. Conklin connects seminar norms to her district’s restorative circles initiative, noting that both structures value empathy, perspective-taking, and productive conflict—skills urgently needed in today’s polarized climate.

Throughout the seminar, discussions remain rooted in textual evidence, reinforcing the importance of citing sources and grounding arguments. At the close, the reflection and summary phase allows students to synthesize insights and evaluate their participation, promoting metacognition.

Conklin concludes by emphasizing the social-emotional benefits: Socratic seminars create a community in which students feel seen, heard, and valued. Citing Ed Research for Action, she notes that students experience stronger school connection when teachers intentionally build relationships and acknowledge individual needs. Seminar provides a structured yet flexible platform for meaningful connection.

Ultimately, Socratic seminars empower middle school students academically and emotionally. They elevate student voice, foster critical thought, and cultivate empathy—preparing adolescents for future civic and academic challenges.

Original Article

Conklin, M. M. (2025, November 24). How Socratic Seminars Can Empower Middle School Students. Edutopia. Original article: https://www.edutopia.org/article/how-socratic-seminars-can-empower-...

------------------------------

Prepared with the assistance of AI software

OpenAI. (2025). ChatGPT (4) [Large language model]. https://chat.openai.com