American Exceptionalism By Robert Schwartz

American Exceptionalism

By Robert Schwartz

One of the issue areas I've paid most attention to in the last few years is teacher policy, an area in which it is pretty clear that the U.S. has a lot to learn from other nations. It's also clear, unfortunately, that many American educators and policymakers simply don't believe the experience of other nations applies to us.

Why is that? When you cut through the rhetoric and the excuses, the underlying belief that explains our refusal to pay attention to what other countries do is that we are different. We're America, with such a unique history, culture, politics, governance system, etc. that nothing that works anywhere else could possibly apply here.

If Finland and Singapore draw their teachers from the top quartile of secondary school students, that's great for them, but of course we couldn't possibly do that. Their cultures must have a long history of deep respect for teachers, whereas we are the country of "those who can, do; those who can't, teach."

When I tell people the reason Finland has ten applicants for every teacher training slot is that the government made a conscious decision not so long ago to raise standards by moving teacher preparation from separate teacher training colleges (the counterparts of our old normal schools) into their universities and requiring all teachers to go through a rigorous five year program leading to a Master's degree, they say, "We couldn't do that. Our universities couldn't possibly meet the demand, and this would result in major teacher shortages."

When I point out that Teach for America has definitively demonstrated that highly talented applicants are attracted, not repelled, by a very competitive admissions process, the counter, of course, is that TFA only asks its recruits for a two-year commitment. The idea that we might try to figure out some way to combine the recruiting strategy of TFA with the training provided by our very strongest university-based preparation programs to create an entering teacher force that begins to resemble that of Finland or Singapore doesn't seem to be on anyone's policy screen. Why? Because we're different from those places, we're America.

Of course, culture and context matter, and you can't simply transplant policies that work in one country to another. But, why bother participating in international assessments of student learning if we are not going to make a serious attempt to study the policies and processes that seem to produce consistently better and more equitable results than we are able to get from our schools?

Robert B. Schwartz is the academic dean and Francis Keppel Professor of Practice at the Harvard Graduate School of Education. He has played a variety of roles in education and government over the past four decades, including high school teacher and principal, foundation officer, and president of Achieve Inc. in Washington.

Views: 106

Comment

You need to be a member of School Leadership 2.0 to add comments!

Join School Leadership 2.0

Comment by Bill Burkhead on April 8, 2011 at 6:38pm
Mr. Schwartz, you are right on!  10 Finnish teachers contacted our superintendent recently to see if they could visit some of our English classes - they are #1 in the world, yet still hungry to get better and stay on top.  Are we sending teachers to Finland or Singapore?  Are we too fat and happy to learn from others?  The terribly nasty C word (Complacency) comes to mind when reading your article.  I know that I personally read everything I can about the success stories of other countries and attempt to use what I can in my school.  One small step!

FOLLOW SL 2.0

JOIN SL 2.0

SUBSCRIBE TO

SCHOOL LEADERSHIP 2.0

School Leadership 2.0 is the premier virtual learning community for school leaders from around the globe.  Our community is a subscription based paid service ($19.95/year or only $1.99 per month for a trial membership)  which will provide school leaders with outstanding resources. Learn more about membership to this service by clicking one our links below.

 

Click HERE to subscribe as an individual.

 

Click HERE to learn about group membership (i.e. association, leadership teams)

__________________

CREATE AN EMPLOYER PROFILE AND GET JOB ALERTS AT 

SCHOOLLEADERSHIPJOBS.COM

SCHOOL LEADERSHIP 2.0 EVENTS

School Leadership 2.0

© 2024   Created by William Brennan and Michael Keany   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service