Asynchronous Interviews - Pros and Cons

​One-way recorded video interviews, also known as asynchronous interviews, have become increasingly prevalent in modern hiring processes. These interviews require candidates to record their responses to pre-set questions without the presence of a live interviewer. While this method offers certain conveniences, it also presents notable challenges and criticisms.​

Advantages of One-Way Video Interviews

1. Scheduling Flexibility: Candidates can complete the interview at their convenience, eliminating the need to coordinate schedules with recruiters. This flexibility is particularly beneficial for applicants in different time zones or those balancing other commitments.​

2. Standardization: All candidates receive the same questions in the same format, ensuring a uniform interview experience. This consistency can help reduce potential biases arising from variations in interviewer questioning styles.​

3. Efficiency for Recruiters: Hiring managers can review interviews at their own pace, allowing them to manage their time more effectively. This can expedite the initial screening process, especially when dealing with a large pool of applicants.​

Criticisms and Concerns

1. Lack of Interaction: Traditional interviews are dynamic, allowing for back-and-forth dialogue. One-way interviews eliminate this interaction, preventing candidates from asking clarifying questions or engaging in a natural conversation. This can hinder the candidate's ability to fully express their qualifications and enthusiasm for the role.​

2. Increased Candidate Burden: Preparing for a one-way interview requires candidates to find a suitable environment, manage recording equipment, and often respond without real-time feedback. This setup can be stressful and may disadvantage those without access to necessary technology or a quiet space.​

3. Potential for Bias: While standardization aims to reduce bias, the visual nature of video interviews can inadvertently introduce biases related to a candidate's appearance, background setting, or perceived socioeconomic status.​

4. Privacy and Data Security: Candidates may have concerns about how their video data is stored, used, or shared. The lack of transparency in some platforms regarding data handling practices can deter applicants.​

5. Impersonal Experience: The absence of human interaction can make the process feel mechanical and impersonal, potentially deterring top talent who seek a more engaging recruitment experience.​

Expert Opinions

Alison Green, a renowned career advisor, expresses strong reservations about one-way video interviews. She argues that they place an unreasonable burden on candidates, requiring significant effort without the opportunity for mutual engagement. Green also points out the inefficiency for hiring managers, as reviewing numerous video responses can be more time-consuming than traditional application assessments. ​Ask a Manager

Conclusion

While one-way recorded video interviews offer certain logistical advantages, they also come with significant drawbacks that can impact both candidates and employers. Organizations should carefully consider these factors when designing their recruitment processes to ensure they attract and fairly assess the best talent.

​Original Article

Source: What's the deal with one-way recorded video interviews?

------------------------------

Prepared with the assistance of AI software

OpenAI. (2025). ChatGPT (4) [Large language model]. https://chat.openai.com